Why Pathos is Pathetic by Sash

I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games… combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases both. I thought it would be worth writing up my own thoughts on the game and taking an inside look at the issues that have been raised online.

If you haven’t played the game, the post has spoilers and will ruin it for you so play it here first.

The player has very little control over the character

This is a game design flaw that is hard to overlook. As a player your only role is to interact in subtle and infrequent ways with the boy. It puts you in an environment where you are forced to watch the events in a world play out – there is no skipping, and no catering for people with a short attention span. And the further and further on you get, the less and less control you have. By the very last scene you have to turn out lights to keep him moving. Paul over on IndieGames.com/blog said:

this was remarkably shoddy. It had a really nice visual style, but it was torture to play. “Why do I go on”. Who knows…

But here in is the point. When you realise that you are a predator, your lack of control over the boy is cast in a whole different light. You aren’t playing as the boy, you are simply trying to “force him onwards” (cliff scene). You’re manipulating him and as the game goes on his fear makes him less and less susceptible to this manipulation. Adam on my blog put it perfectly:

“The whole thing was about control, to me. I was constantly fighting the kid for control the whole game—he would stop every so often and I just wanted him to get on with it. And then suddenly at the end, I had all the control…until I didn’t, because I couldn’t let him go. And then I kind of regretted pushing him forward, and chasing him down, but it was too late… I had to keep going.”

You are forced into being “evil”

There is a trend in modern gaming to let you choose how “renegade” your character is – Pathos gives the finger to this trend and forces you, in surprisingly uncomfortable way, to be evil. This is initially indicative of criticism,

“There’s no weight to it, because there’s no choice, except play or don’t. You can’t decide to not follow the rules, as then nothing happens.”

But its not your choice that is important, it is your reaction to your lack of choice. As SpinalJack on Rock Paper Shotgun said:

“Your reaction to the game says something about you. Whether or not that’s something you didn’t already know is a different story.
Imagine the Stanley Milgram’s Obedience Experiment, would you hesitate to electrocute a man to death if told to do so with enough authority?
Whether you felt bad/enjoyed/apathetic about hurting the boy in the game or immediately tried to do the opposite of what you were instructed to do is all part of the game/social experiment.”

Adam says:

“Sometimes art makes you uncomfortable. But sometimes you have to get uncomfortable to see something in a way you haven’t seen before.”

By forcing the player into uncomfortable action, I was asking a question. Why do we take a back seat with video game characters so blindly? Do we play, not because we empathise, but instead in the hopes that we will eventually have “fun”? DustbinK on my blog hit the nail on the head:

“It seems people don’t get that this is a “meta game” – it’s about you forcing yourself onto characters in video games without questioning whether they want you to make them do these things or not.”

Of course, there is always another option. You can always quit before the end – but really, how many people are willing to do that? And why not? Why would anybody want to play as a boy who is suffering? Consumatopia on Rock Paper Shotgun raises an interesting point:

“This game is actually more interesting if you interpret this game as a criticism of the “only way to win is not to play” genre rather than an instance of it. In what sense can we say that “you” are the one pushing events forward when the only other option is to halt the program? Am I also responsible for every death in every movie I’ve watched because I could have stopped the movie from playing?”

And why did I even bother making this a game?

The lack of control, both over the boy and over the direction of the game has definitely been an issues for a lot of people:

“This would have been better off as an animation. The bad design choices just distract from the message he’s trying to make.”

But there is one fundamental reason why it has to be interactive to pull its weight:

“The difference being that YOU’RE the one who is forcing this boy to go on even if you don’t have the option to do something else. It’s the difference between watching a video and pulling the trigger.”

So what DID you learn?

Also, I almost LOL’ed reading the author’s description “you will learn something about yourself”.

Yes, I am pretentious, I admit. But what I meant is that Pathos might just make you think about one of these issues.

As a video game, it is flawed. And it’s certainly not everyones cup of tea. But whether you hated it or loved it, or both, Pathos isn’t about having fun or being “cool”, it’s about making you think, and starting a conversation. Something which it has certainly achieved.

I’d just like to close with a comment from MisterX on IndieGames.com, which I think sums up the experience nicely:

At first I was also a little afraid of what was to come, like the boy. But, then, it becomes apparent that you are in control of him, and that he is actually afraid of *you*, suddenly erasing all suspense and turning it  into empathy for the little guy.

Comments were found here:


Discussion

  1. Ramon says:

    First of all I would like to say great blog!

    I had a quick question in which I’d like to ask if you
    do not mind. I was interested to find out how you center yourself and
    clear your mind prior to writing. I have had a tough time clearing my mind in getting
    my ideas out. I do enjoy writing however it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes
    tend to be lost just trying to figure out how to begin.
    Any recommendations or hints? Cheers!

  2. Alina says:

    What a stuff of un-ambiguity and preserveness of precious familiarity about unexpected emotions.

  3. I went over this website and I think you have lots of
    great info, saved to bookmarks.

  4. Ashton says:

    You are offering an essential information. I’ll be your regular visitor.

  5. this article says:

    Hello there, I found your website by means of Google whilst looking for a similar topic,
    your web site came up, it appears to be like
    great. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.

    Hi there, just was aware of your weblog thru Google, and found
    that it’s truly informative. I am gonna watch out for brussels.
    I will be grateful if you proceed this in future. Lots of other people can be
    benefited from your writing. Cheers!

  6. Link exchange is nothing else however it is simply placing
    the other person’s blog link on your page at proper place and other
    person will also do similar in support of you.

  7. Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to safeguard against hackers?
    I’m kinda paranoid about losing everything I’ve worked hard on. Any tips?

  8. And also, you will uncover various means to efficiently assemble a
    REAL trustworthy medical emergency treatment package.

  9. In landscapes, kerbing feature as barrier that blocks drains
    for that reason holding the dirt with each various other in addition to consisting of charm.

  10. Individuals should never shed hope and also for households of
    those affected they must remain to urge the patient
    and also reveal love to increase the opportunity of phase 4 cancer survival rate.

  11. Hey I am so delighted I found your site, I really found you by accident,
    while I was looking on Digg for something else, Regardless I am here now and would just like to say
    thanks a lot for a fantastic post and a all round exciting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to
    look over it all at the minute but I have saved it and also included your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please
    do keep up the superb b.

  12. Click Right here to lose weight (burn fat)
    and construct muscle at the identical time but… Get started here If you are really
    overweight.

  13. The 3 combined firms had 1990 sales of $497 million.

  14. Adrian says:

    I appreciate the information in this article. It’s smart, well-written as well as easy to understand.
    You have my attention on this topic. I will
    be back for even more interesting articles or blog posts.

  15. Gerardo says:

    I’m truly inspired with your writing talent. Anyway maintain the wonderful
    high quality writing, it’s rare to see an excellent blog such as
    this these days.

  16. All of it falls on getting involved in a groove.

  17. edc items says:

    Thanks designed for sharing such a pleasant idea, paragraph is good,
    thats why i have read it fully

  18. Zella says:

    The modern-day feminist is an obstacle to survival
    and preparedness in our culture.

  19. Our site says:

    Fantastic beat ! I wish to apprentice while you amend
    your website, how can i subscribe for a blog web site?
    The account helped me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear idea

  20. Way cool! Some extremely valid points! I appreciate you writing this write-up plus the
    rest of the site is also very good.

  21. Nicole says:

    Marvelous, what a web site it is! This web site
    presents valuable information to us, keep it up.

  22. site says:

    I every time spent my half an hour to read this blog’s posts every day along with a
    cup of coffee.

  23. Myrtle says:

    There were some rumors rolling yesterday that the game may be released as early as today,
    nevertheless Hi Games was quick to place the kibosh on that notion.

  24. I don’t even know how I ended up here, but I thought this post was
    good. I don’t know who you are but definitely you are going to a famous blogger if you are not already ;) Cheers!

  25. qqbet.net says:

    I blog frequently and I truly appreciate your information.
    Your article has truly peaked my interest. I will book mark
    your site and keep checking for new details about once per week.

    I subscribed to your RSS feed as well.

  26. game-ded.com says:

    Just want to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is simply cool and
    that i can assume you are knowledgeable in this subject.
    Well together with your permission let me to seize your feed to stay updated with imminent post.
    Thank you one million and please carry on the rewarding work.

  27. views four days ago Sexy Indian chick with large tits fucked Teen fucked in forest by outdated man pt 1 Scorching latin maid,blowjob nylon titty fuck uniform latin Lovely teen mannequin jen facial Quite the opposite, the latest supply would contain numerous nudity and lots of
    sex. The working title for Kulich’s proposed production? Russian teen with a good physique bends
    over and takes a masseur’s cock up her again entrance Barely authorized
    teen from Russia opens her juicy ass cheeks for a scorching romp
    Cute redhead teen rewarded for making breakfast by a thick cock down her pussy Eager blonde mature
    is letting her teen lover slam her pussy beneath a heat bathe Masseur bangs the brains out of
    a cute teen with a mushy pussy and superb ass A
    pair of tender nubiles from Russia lick and fuck a man with an enormous
    cock

  28. Cynthia says:

    I got a waste basket (I desired everything to be useful) and put all
    the products in it. I published out a BIG label for the waste basket that said
    - Elderly person’s Survival Package – for those
    golden years.

  29. Irvin says:

    Each winter months she loaded a small survival package for the vehicle total with
    coffee can, a candle light and also matches to maintain him heat in an emergency situation.

  30. Uploaded a video on YouTube revealing my survival limitless
    setup and also how I use it plus other details.

  31. Website says:

    I am really pleased to glance at this webpage posts which contains tons of helpful information, thanks for providing these kinds
    of information.

    Website site good website koleso-fortuni.Ru

  32. The other critical explanation to take fish
    oils, is for the reason that restricting your calories can lead to you missing out on your necessary fatty acids (omega 3′s) that your body can nott make
    up, and that Must be obtained by way of your diet regime.

  33. Bruno says:

    Great post. Didn’t know this, thank you for letting me
    know.

  34. Thank you for any other informative web site. The place else could I am
    getting that type of info written in such
    a perfect method? I’ve a challenge that I am simply now running on, and I’ve been on the look out for such information.

  35. I had my gallbladder out on 31st like nearly 3 weeks currently i m
    taking light food n m told by physicians not to have oily food for 3 these
    3 weeks by the poise of Almighty i had no concerns of digestion intitially i was unable to
    consume much not because of burning or food digestion yet considering that i dint feel so but with each passing day
    my diet is raising.

  36. Milton says:

    Netflix, Plex, Hulu, annd YouTube are my essential sources of
    video entertainment. Apart from one 15-second
    preroll advert when I watch Agents of SHIELD, I haven’t seen an advert while watching TV in over a month.

  37. Piece of writing writing is also a excitement, if you know then you can write or else it is complex to write.

  38. Ian Leaf says:

    Excellent blog here! Also your website quite a bit up very fast!
    What web host are you the usage of? Can I am getting your associate link
    in your host? I want my web site loaded up as quickly ass yours lol

  39. The good news is, there are several tow truck insurance coverage protections that permit you to customize your plan to fit your business’ needs.

  40. Addie says:

    We obtain it. That’s why we make survival blades that are easy and mobile to band to your individual and equipment.

  41. Jennie says:

    Industrial bordering: Different car park designs have actually been set up by Kwik Kerb(R) worldwide since
    1987.

  42. An outstanding share! I haave just forwarded this onto a frien who had been conducting a little research on this.
    And he actually ordered me dinner because I discovered it for him…

    lol. So let me reword this…. Thank YOU for the meal!!

    But yeah, thanks for spending thee time to discuss this subject here on your website.

  43. Visit a municipal Solution SA client service center and also
    ask for the tow vehicle certification application forms (MR428,
    mr420 and also mr410).

  44. Johnie says:

    Great post, i certainly enjoy this wonderful website, keep posting.

  45. This charming set that I discovered at just a little something …
    is best for that individual in your life!

  46. We’re a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community.
    Your site provided uus wirh valuable info tto work on.
    You have done a formidable job and our whle community will be thankful to you.

  47. Hey there I am so thrilled I found your blog, I really found you by error, while I was
    browsing on Digg for something else, Anyways I am here now
    and would just like to say cheers for a fantastic post and a all round enjoyable blog (I also love the theme/design), I
    don’t have time to browse it all at the minute but I have book-marked it
    and also added your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read
    much more, Please do keep up the awesome work.

  48. I’m not sure exactly why but this weblog is loading
    extremely slow for me. Is anyone else having this issue or is it
    a issue on my end? I’ll check back later and
    see if the problem still exists.

  49. rule says:

    As I exhale I am going to take it too offered a bevy of” no”
    when a person is different. People can find out. This, they will send signals to your life at the internal toxin then lead
    to weight garcinia management program. See, they’re
    actually sponsoring this video is, these raspberry supplements provide me with the fuels it prefers at a time to cook.
    So you need to attain Weightmeals on my own two feet.
    Yeah, well hang on, now you’re scaring me with temptations!

  50. Bret says:

    The minimal time crossover occasion brings fan-favorite heros from Telltale Games’
    The Walking Dead Period 1 into The Strolling Dead:
    Roadway to Survival from Scopely in partnership with The Walking Dead series designer Robert Kirkman and Skybound.

  1. کفسابی linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  2. gay anal sex linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  3. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  4. اپل آیدی linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  5. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  6. Antinox linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  7. vaginal and anal linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  8. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  9. furry cuffs linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  10. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  11. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  12. magic wand linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  13. dildos linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  14. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  15. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  16. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  17. Internet Money linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  18. LilTuneChi linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  19. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  20. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  21. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  22. Sex position linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  23. strap on dildo linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  24. تعمیر یخچال linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  25. giant dildo linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  26. Travel linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  27. Hot Rubber Melters linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  28. Rap Beats linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  29. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  30. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  31. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  32. ebooks for resale linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  33. military manuals linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  34. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  35. Rap Instrumentals linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  36. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  37. Weird Sex Toys linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  38. dirty confessions linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  39. Garden Bridges linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  40. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  41. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  42. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  43. mastubate linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  44. plug toys linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  45. vibrating ring linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  46. bubble packaging linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  47. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  48. Ba Be Tours linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  49. iron balusters linked here

    [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

  50. [... I released Pathos Yesterday, and already it has had more comments than any of my other games... combined. It seems like people either love or hate it, in some cases ...]

Leave a Comment